Rewarding Excellence, Creating Dysfunction: The Hidden Cost of Automatic Promotion Practices
Organizations routinely celebrate their strongest individual contributors by placing them in management roles—yet this well-intentioned practice consistently produces underperforming leaders and demoralized teams. Understanding the structural logic behind this pattern is the first step toward dismantling it. This article examines why the skills that drive individual excellence frequently conflict with the demands of effective leadership, and how organizations can build smarter pathways to the ma